Ruby Walsh conjured a late rally out of Back In Focus to deny Aupcharlie as Willie Mullins claimed a one-two in the Topaz Novice Chase at Leopardstown.
The strong-travelling Aupcharlie was going the better on the run to the final fence but he pecked slightly on landing and could not pull far enough clear of his nearest pursuer.
Walsh kept at the Graham Wylie-owned seven-year-old on the long run-in and the 6-4 favourite battled on bravely to get up close home to score by a head. Texas Jack was third.
Mount Benbulben was pulled up after making a bad mistake as the field went out for the final circuit, while Tony McCoy's partner Jenari fell at the following fence and Lyreen Legend came down three out.
Mullins said: "That's a fantastic win. We didn't think for one minute that Ruby would get back up until he did. He needs every inch of three miles and ground even softer that that. He's a real winter horse.
"As much as I'm delighted I'm sorry for Aupcharlie and Andrew Lynch. It was only his second run over fences and he's run a fantastic race.
"Back In Focus has the RSA written all over him. We'll look for a race over three miles for him.
"With Aupcharlie we could look for the Dr P.J Moriarty. We'll keep them apart. There is no point in them taking each other on again. Aupcharlie could be a horse for the Jewson. The way he jumped he could even come back to the minimum trip. They are two horses to look forward to."
Stan James cut Back In Focus to 12-1 from 16s for the RSA, with Aupcharlie 10-1 from 16-1 for the Jewson Novices' Chase.
Spokesman Joseph Burke said: "Back In Focus proved he's all about stamina after he just got up to prevail by a head on the line from stablemate Aupcharlie, who appeared to just run out of steam. Willie Mullins won the Jewson last season with Sir Des Champs."
7 October 2015One-day bans for riders in Kempton 'wrong stalls' incident
Ryan Moore takes the plaudits with Nottingham victory
Bertimont injury blow for Dan Skelton
Winning start over fences for smart hurdler Violet Dancer
Grand National winner Pineau De Re set for final season
Gordon Elliott outlines early plans for stable star Don Cossack
Wesley Ward keen to secure Frankie Dettori for Breeders' Cup rides
Sam Twiston-Davies relishing top job with Paul Nicholls
Nick Attenborough and John Blake take up charity roles
Rain wanted for Cirrus Des Aigles ahead of Champions Day at Ascot
New series of races announced by BHA and Jockey Club Racecourses
Aidan O'Brien's Minding and Coolmore lead Fillies' Mile field at Newmarket
Andre Fabre waiting on Esoterique Breeders' Cup decision
Aidan O'Brien decides against sending Order Of St George to Melbourne
Nicky Richards considering Cheltenham target for Simply Ned
Ascot ground key to Decorated Knight's QEII run
Market Rasen option for Malcolm Jefferson's Cyrus Darius
Air Force Blue on track for Dewhurst - Aidan O'Brien
Frankie Dettori dreaming of America for Golden Horn
Mecca's Angel ruled out of Champions Sprint reckoning
Guineas heroine Legatissimo likely to race on in 2016
Eduard injury blow for Nicky Richards
Paddy Power option for David Pipe's Kings Palace
Andre Fabre unveils Lockinge option for Make Believe
Andre Fabre hoping for 2016 campaign with Arc third New Bay
Henry Candy eager to step up to a mile with Foret second Limato
6 October 2015Seamour heads strong British presence in Irish Cesarewitch
Frankie Dettori 'extremely grateful' for support of Sheikh Joaan in dream season
Cheltenham's new stand to debut at The Open meeting
Ed Walker considering French trip for Persona Grata
David Marnane mulling Lingfield run for Jamesie
Saint-Cloud aim for Harry Dunlop's Robin Of Navan
Warren Greatrex issues Cole Harden Wetherby warning
Champion-elect Silvestre De Sousa lands Pontefract double
David Pipe "optimistic" of a bold show from Low Key in Cesarewitch
David Pipe considers French return for Dynaste
Charlie Hall Chase at Wetherby an option for National hero Many Clouds
No decision yet on Free Eagle's future plans
Anthony Oppenheimer eager to tackle Breeders' Cup challenge with Golden Horn
Godolphin and Coolmore big guns all set for Dewhurst clash
Hugo Palmer in no hurry to decide Covert Love plan
Criquette Head- Maarek focusing on her post-Treve future
5 October 2015Pascal Bary reveals Antonoe suffered pelvic injury in Boussac defeat
Low Key one of 56 remaining in Cesarewitch
Chelmsford hoping to introduce seven-furlong chute this month
Joe Tuite excited by Field Of Vision's Cornwallis claims
Joe Tuite maps out Ascot aim for Litigant after Longchamp withdrawal
Freddy Head hoping for Ascot rain ahead of Solow QEII bid
Wetherby target for Neil Mulholland's Aintree hope The Druids Nephew
Arc-winning rider Frankie Dettori misses Monday Windsor rides
Make Believe floors Limato in Prix de la Foret
Sovereign Debt on top in Tipperary drama
Goldream speeds to Prix de l'Abbaye victory for Robert Cowell
Treve set to bow out after Longchamp defeat
Golden Horn storms to Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe glory at Longchamp
Covert Love digs deep to give Hugo Palmer big-race glory at Longchamp
Ultra impressive for Andre Fabre in Lagardere
Ballydoyle strikes for Aidan O'Brien in Prix Marcel Boussac
Andrea Atzeni leaves Qatar Racing to ride for Sheikh Mohammed Obaid
4 October 2015Qatar hero Dubday returning home
John Gosden's Mr Singh to stay in training
Dutch Connection only fifth in Shadwell Mile at Keeneland
Tuite in confident mood ahead of Litigant's Cadran test at Longchamp
Palmer thrilled with Covert Love condition ahead of Opera assignment
Storm looks a Star in the making after Cumberland Lodge stroll at Ascot
Lester Piggott backing Treve to claim historic third Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe
Cirrus Des Aigles beaten in quest for fourth Dollar at Longchamp
Eastern Impact gives red-hot Richard Fahey another big Saturday winner at Ascot
Esoterique cuts down Integral to take Sun Chariot prize
Log Out Island lifts Two-Year-Old Trophy at Redcar
Gifted Master runs rivals ragged to claim big Newmarket prize
No joy for British hope The Twisler as Vazirabad dazzles in Chaudenay
Mecca's Angel misses Abbaye due to drying ground