Minella Forfitness got up in the last stride to deny Cheltenian a winning comeback in the SIG Insulation EBF "National Hunt" Novices' Hurdle at Doncaster.
The 9-4 favourite was only third over the final flight, but responded to Barry Geraghty's urgings on the drive to the line to strike by a short head.
"He ran a bit with the choke out so I had to wait until he filled up again. I think he's suited by further. It was only after the last when I felt I had a chance. He's more of a horse for next year," said Geraghty.
While disappointed at the agonising defeat, trainer Philip Hobbs was delighted with Cheltenian, who was having his first run since winning the Weatherbys Champion Bumper in March 2011.
"He's run fantastic, but it's frustrating that he just got beat. We'll have to see how he is in the couple of weeks. Hopefully he'll go to Cheltenham but he's only had this one run in the last two years," he said.
"He's in the two-mile (Supreme) and the two-mile-five (Neptune Investment Management). We'll have to see what the ground's like but he looks to have plenty of pace for two (miles)."
Geraghty was completing a double for the Henderson team, begun by Otto The Great (5-2) in the 32Red Novices' Chase. Given plenty of room out wide by Barry Geraghty to have a good look at the obstacles, the Nicky Henderson-trained grey put in an assured display to dispense of three rivals.
"He jumped brilliantly. We just got racing a bit early in the straight and galloped into the fourth-last. Apart from that he was foot perfect. He didn't win over hurdles but had some great runs. He disappointed at Newbury, but we always knew he would take to fences," said Geraghty.
Hobbs and jockey Richard Johnson gained some compensation for Cheltenian's defeat when Doctor Foxtrot (20-1) overcame a 518-day absence to win the SIS Live Handicap Hurdle and deny Geraghty, on the length-and-a-quarter runner-up Mister Dillon, a treble.
Tom O'Brien will miss the Cheltenham Festival after he was hit with a 10-day suspension in Minella Forfitness' race. O'Brien was found guilty of "failing to take all reasonable and permissible measures to obtain the best possible placing" aboard Benefit Cut, who finished seventh.
3 May 2015Top marks for Gosden and Dettori
Bolger smiling in defeat
Guineas double for magical Moore
'Incredible' Aigles does it again
Lockinge date for Integral
Bragging rights for Stoute
Snow in frame for Chester
Astronereus stars for Perrett
Gleneagles team eye Curragh
No hiding place for Found
Ribbons sets sail for York
Ascot beckons for willing Able
Callaghan thrilled with brave Line
Kazeem raring to go in Ganay
Fabre keen on another go at Glen
Schofield breaks new ground
Petite another star for Mullins
No mistakes from Annie
Guineas glory for Gleneagles
Step too far for Telescope
Gold-en result for Cowell
Balty too hot for Newmarket rivals
Nam 'ready to go' in Pretty Polly
2 May 2015Oscar highlight of McManus show
Friend is ready, willing and Able
Elm withdrawn from Guineas
Baffert sights set on Kentucky
Eyes right for Henderson
Classy Canyon strikes again
Faugheen strolls to Champion glory
Blood-less success for Mullins
Moore looking forward to Glen
Rizeena takes distance test
Lucida on target for big run
Muir ace out to make a point
Murphy ready to rock at Brighton
1 May 2015McDonogh has focus on victory
Annie powered up for redemption
Colgan fine following fall
Telescope sights set on Newmarket
Hannon hoping for Guineas double
Gleneagles primed for Classic date
Hannon hoping for Guineas double
Found misses Guineas test
Murphy in surprise Flat move
Diomed option for Ascription
Uncle sparks Mullins five-timer
Sceaux far so good
Jezki swats old rival Fly
Jackson battles to victory
Weld ace to head down Derby route
Canyon seeking fourth Grade One
Elm team to make late call
Faugheen bids for perfect finale
Power misses Palace date
Power stars in Mares Champion field
30 April 2015Bolster team mull future plans
Qualando seeking Grade One glory
Certain makes Muguet return
Gerard option for Chase
Godolphin duo miss Guineas date
Axom snap up Fontana
Wales's is likely Criterion target
Approach earns Guinness honours
Dynamite Don proves pure Gold
Bellshill another for Mullins
Vic hangs on to deny Thistle raid
Limato keeps unbeaten run going
Ascot hopes for Aktabantay
Mizzou puts down Gold Cup marker
Sceaux much to enjoy in Ryanair
No Fly stamina worries for Mullins