Minella Forfitness got up in the last stride to deny Cheltenian a winning comeback in the SIG Insulation EBF "National Hunt" Novices' Hurdle at Doncaster.
The 9-4 favourite was only third over the final flight, but responded to Barry Geraghty's urgings on the drive to the line to strike by a short head.
"He ran a bit with the choke out so I had to wait until he filled up again. I think he's suited by further. It was only after the last when I felt I had a chance. He's more of a horse for next year," said Geraghty.
While disappointed at the agonising defeat, trainer Philip Hobbs was delighted with Cheltenian, who was having his first run since winning the Weatherbys Champion Bumper in March 2011.
"He's run fantastic, but it's frustrating that he just got beat. We'll have to see how he is in the couple of weeks. Hopefully he'll go to Cheltenham but he's only had this one run in the last two years," he said.
"He's in the two-mile (Supreme) and the two-mile-five (Neptune Investment Management). We'll have to see what the ground's like but he looks to have plenty of pace for two (miles)."
Geraghty was completing a double for the Henderson team, begun by Otto The Great (5-2) in the 32Red Novices' Chase. Given plenty of room out wide by Barry Geraghty to have a good look at the obstacles, the Nicky Henderson-trained grey put in an assured display to dispense of three rivals.
"He jumped brilliantly. We just got racing a bit early in the straight and galloped into the fourth-last. Apart from that he was foot perfect. He didn't win over hurdles but had some great runs. He disappointed at Newbury, but we always knew he would take to fences," said Geraghty.
Hobbs and jockey Richard Johnson gained some compensation for Cheltenian's defeat when Doctor Foxtrot (20-1) overcame a 518-day absence to win the SIS Live Handicap Hurdle and deny Geraghty, on the length-and-a-quarter runner-up Mister Dillon, a treble.
Tom O'Brien will miss the Cheltenham Festival after he was hit with a 10-day suspension in Minella Forfitness' race. O'Brien was found guilty of "failing to take all reasonable and permissible measures to obtain the best possible placing" aboard Benefit Cut, who finished seventh.
7 February 2016Nicky Henderson plans to assess Peace And Co
O O Seven has licence to thrill at Musselburgh
Kadrizzi delivers at Chelmsford for Dean Ivory
Gitane Du Berlais stamps class on Listed heat at Naas
Paul Nicholls and Tommy Silver strike Musselburgh gold
Babbling Stream in full flow at Naas for Willie Mullins and Ruby Walsh
Charbel rules supreme at Musselburgh for Kim Bailey
Nigel Twiston-Davies hails Bristol De Mai performance
Victoria Pendleton pulls up Working Title at Wadebridge point-to-point
Le Reve team have sights set on Grand National glory
McCoy retains Ivanovich Gorbatov faith despite Leopardstown eclipse
Leopardstown date set to determine Aspen Colorado Cheltenham plan
Colin Tizzard considering racecourse gallop for Gold Cup contender Cue Card
Jonjo O'Neill favouring Newbury date for More Of That
Grendisar powers to Winter Derby Trial repeat at Lingfield
Sad postscript to Leopardstown hunter chase win for You Must Know Me
Saddlers Encore the hero in Sandown test
Carlingford Lough repeats Irish Gold Cup heroics in Leopardstown drama
Blaklion roars to Towton Chase glory at Wetherby
Outlander strikes in Flogas Chase for Grade One king Willie Mullins
Bristol De Mai on course for Cheltenham and JLT after stylish Scilly Isles win
Bleu Et Rouge too good for Tombstone in Deloitte at Leopardstown
Peace And Co shocked at Sandown as Connetable takes Contenders Hurdle
Ivanovich Gorbatov floored by Willie Mullins' trio in Spring Juvenile Hurdle
6 February 2016Ffos Las officials forced to concede defeat
Double delight for Aidan Coleman at Catterick
Ffos Las fixture subject to second inspection at midday
Andrew Tinkler looking forward to high-profile Musselburgh card
Green light for Ffos Las fixture
Zabana raring to go for Flogas mission
Definitly Red spells danger for Wetherby rivals in Towton Chase
Medinas returns to action at Sandown
Nicky Richards launches dual Welsh Champion raid at Ffos Las
Ffos Las fixture subject to morning check
Hunting star On The Fringe returns at Leopardstown
Can Bellshill give Yanworth something to think about at Leopardstown?
Outlander and Pont Alexandre loom large in Flogas Chase
Triumph Hurdle favourite Ivanovich Gorbatov bids to cement Festival place
Rebecca Curtis runners dominate West Wales National field
Tea For Two targeting Grade One double in Scilly Isles date
Sir Des Champs goes for more Gold for Gigginstown
Noel Meade surprised by Road To Riches' odds in Gold Cup test
Peace And Co out to prove he is a genuine Champion Hurdle contender
5 February 2016Alan King outlines plans for star juveniles
Nina Carberry misses On The Fringe mount following back injury
Victoria Pendleton heads to Wadebridge to continue riding experience
Cold As Ice aiming to sparkle for William Haggas in Cleves outing at Lingfield
American ace Frosted puts down World Cup marker at Meydan
Alan King 'keeps it simple' and focuses solely on Neptune with Yanworth
Henry Daly sets sights on Sandown with Towcester winner Flashjack
Arkwrisht proves best for Willie Mullins at Clonmel
Harry Whittington set to swerve Cheltenham with Arzal
Ivanovich Gorbatov tops Triumph list at Cheltenham Festival
Willie Mullins makes monster Supreme entry at Cheltenham
Howard Johnson - I wouldn't have confidence for a training return
Sandy Thomson rules Seeyouatmidnight out of Wetherby heat
4 February 2016Arkwrisht proves best for Willie Mullins at Clonmel
Lifetime bans to be imposed in Ireland for drug missue
Barters Hill handed Albert Bartlett ticket at Cheltenham Festival
Alan King takes aim at Neptune with classy Yanworth
'Bouncing' Road To Riches thrills Noel Meade before Leopardstown date
Anthony Honeyball considers Lily Waugh Cheltenham Festival target
Michael Scudamore has Next Sensation on track for Cheltenham
Paul Nicholls has weighty Grand National issue with Silviniaco Conti
Welcome winner for Jonjo O'Neill at Ludlow
Saeed bin Suroor pays tribute to 'one of the best' on death of Halling, aged 25
French dark horse Maquisard could enter Triumph Hurdle picture
Allysson Monterg sets Richard Hobson a Festival poser with Leicester win
Zawraq future 'in the balance' following slow recovery process
Jeremy Kyle ITV racing role 'discussed'
Michael Scudamore admits defeat in race to get Monbeg Dude to Aintree
Television ace Brian Gleeson seeking Clonmel riches with Dont Tell No One
Mags Mullins retains faith in World Hurdle contender Martello Tower